Home
Apple uses its extraordinary design and engineering talents to reinvent entire industries. I think the housing market will experience a similar transformation as soon as some smart company creates home designs that make sense in today's world. Imagine how stimulated the economy would be if everyone who could afford a more expensive home really, really, really wanted one. That's a big change from now. Moving to a new home is such a hassle that you won't bother if all you hope to gain is an extra guest room or bigger closets. But in the same way that the first iPhone was more than just a better cellphone - it was a whole new product - I think an extraordinarily well-designed home would also be seen as an entirely new product category. And consumers would wait in line at the bank for mortgage applications.

At the moment, there's almost no such thing as a design premium for homes. A home's value is, for the most part, determined by its location and square footage. Sometimes the home's age and its view enter into the price. But mostly it's about size. That tells you that design has been relegated to a low priority. Home design is somewhere between an afterthought and a generic process anchored in the past.

Suppose a company decided to make a real science out of home design. They could build a number of prototypes and have test families live in them, taking notes about what they like and dislike. This imagined firm could continue tweaking the design until they discovered what mix would command a premium price. I'm talking about home designs so awesome that people who thought they were happy in their existing homes would get buyer's lust, the same way people lust after iPhones.

An important part of the home design would involve figuring out ways to reduce or eliminate ongoing operating and maintenance costs. Ideally, you'd want to avoid any Homeowners Association Fees, and you'd want to reduce cleaning, energy, and repair costs as much as possible. We already know how to build homes that will never need exterior paint. We already know how to bring energy costs to nearly zero. We know how to install artificial turf that needs no mowing and no water, and we know how to design landscaping that needs little or no irrigation. I don't think we need to invent anything new.

I'm a big proponent of rooms that have multiple uses. For example, a home office might have a fold-down bed in the wall cabinetry so the space can double as a guest room. And if you design your dining area right, with casual cushioned chairs, for example, it can double as your home theater space for dinner and a movie.

If you paid a surprise visit to any typical American family on a weekday evening, you might find each person in a different room using a different computer. The kids might be doing homework, or surfing the web, while one parent is catching up on work, and the other is sending out an Evite. Perhaps modern homes should have a comfortable and attractive space near the kitchen and living room, designed for multiple computer users who need ample desk space and comfortable chairs. That way the family can be together while doing their own things.

When I walk through model homes, I'm blown away by the lack of thought that goes into locating the fireplace and the TV. Putting the flat screen TV over the fireplace is a design no-no. That's a box over a box. The ideal home would involve an L-shaped couch with one view facing a fireplace and the other facing a TV. That configuration looks right, and it's perfectly functional.

Ideally, the kitchen would be designed from the ground up as a gathering place and not just a work space. Everyone ends up in the kitchen anyway, so you might as well make it comfortable. The perfect kitchen would have a center island with stool seats, and be open to both the dining area and living room.

You often see bar serving areas in high-end homes, located in nooks off the living rooms. That seems like a good idea until you start carrying ice and glasses and beverages back and forth from the kitchen. Why not make the bar an extension of the kitchen so everything is handy?

After my wife and I built our current home, I was surprised to discover that some spaces are naturally inviting and others feel lonely. You can feel the difference as you walk from one room to another. Our minds and bodies have very specific preferences about space, and that's the sort of thing that can be tested with prototype homes. You can't guess how a home will feel by looking at blueprints.

Case in point, when we entertain, everyone crowds into a little triangle that technically isn't even a room. It's more of a transition between two spaces. But you could do the experiment at our house a hundred times, with a hundred different groups, and they'd all end up standing in the same little triangular area to socialize. None of that could have been predicted by the floor plans.

We put a ping pong table in one end of our garage, with a good sound system and some used furniture. The space is framed by storage closets, tools, a minivan, and a water heater. The garage is dusty and unfinished. But when we have friends over, especially kids, it often turns into the center of activity. Everyone feels comfortable in that sort of space. As a bonus, the ping pong table makes a great utility table for all sorts of temporary projects.

We designed our house to be pet friendly. The dog has her own little outdoor space with artificial grass to do her business unattended. The cat has her own cat box facility off the laundry room, with a raised platform so we don't have to bend over to clean the cat box. Pets are like little love batteries for the home; you give them affection, and later they return the favor when you need a lift. Homes should be designed with pets in mind.

I can imagine homes designed for particular lifestyles. For example, some people are bicycle enthusiasts, and you can imagine designing the garage and workbench area in a way that would make a cyclist drool. Other people might be into art or crafts, or need an awesome home office.

A few years ago, I bought a massage chair. It does its job well, and I think I love it, but there's no elegant place for it in the house. It doesn't go with our other furniture, and because it reclines, it's inconvenient to keep it near a wall. Why not design a house with an inviting and convenient place for a massage chair? And while we're at it, let's make the master bath area more like a lovely escape than a mere extension of the bathroom decor.

Now imagine that the well-designed home has screaming-fast Internet connections, high end sound systems in every room, a home theater, and advanced lighting controls. You'd never want to leave the house. But wait, it's all too expensive, right?

Imagine looking at this model home in the early evening. The lighting creates a tranquil scene in each room. The high-end ceiling speakers surround you in music streamed from the Internet. You see the gathering area in the kitchen and imagine the fun you would have cooking and socializing. You walk past the area specially designed for the massage chair and wish you were in it. You pass the master bath, with the waterfall flowing into a warm bath in a spa-like setting. You see the computer nook that comfortably seats four. You see the home theater that doubles as a dining area just a few steps from the kitchen, with its three microwaves for movie night popcorn production. The house's price is 30% more than you'd pay for the same square footage in an ordinary house. But you lust for the house anyway. It must be yours. That's the design premium. I think good design could revitalize the entire housing industry.

 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +69
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
Mar 6, 2012
Another nice aspect of this sort of standardization is that shopping remotely would be much easier. If you knew you wanted a house in Memphis or San Francisco (suburbs), verifying the neighborhood is the only requirement since you would already have seen the house locally (provided a local expo). Houses don't really need to be much more custom than cars for most folks.
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 29, 2012
This is a great idea if you plan on living in the same home until "death-do-you-part," but if you have even the slightest notion that you're going to someday sell the home, you might be creating a home that would be extremely difficult to sell to someone else.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 26, 2012
My thought was why would you want microwave popcorn at all? Pan- or air-popped is so much better, there's no comparison. Are people not willing to wait 5 minutes for good popcorn, or what?
 
 
Feb 25, 2012
There's actually a book about this concept, calle "A Timeless Way of Building". It's about understanding the subconscious psychology of humans individually and in groups and designing homes based on the patterns of use, surrounding landscape, neighboring properties, etc. I first read it as an introduction to pattern languages while working at Microsoft; many of the same principles apply when building software. It's not an afternoon read, by any means, but I can recommend it for anyone in design in pretty much any industry.
 
 
Feb 25, 2012
Um, I can't believe you just planned cubicles in your house!
 
 
Feb 25, 2012
What I'd really like is designs and furnishings that facilitated quick and easy conversions of rooms. For a very simple example, a coffee table that folds flat. You use this with a sofa bed: When it's in bed mode the table slides under it for less clutter, and when it's in sofa mode the room becomes a bit friendlier as an office, study, etc.
Slightly more advanced: Serious shades or self-opaqueing glass that darken a sunny family room sufficiently to serve as a home theater, and vanish from view in family room mode. High-end folding table and chairs with their own closet, so the dining room can be used for something else the 358 days of the year a dining room isn't used. Aesthetic and practical concealment of flatscreens (and other technology) when not in use: artwork, sliding panels, rolling bookcases. Right now we have big pieces of furniture, and while cabinet doors are an improvement over a bare screen I'd like to make better use of that wall space.
Probably not practical: A counter between family room and kitchen that rolls one way to expand the family room for the kids to play; and rolls the other to expand the kitchen for ambitious meals and social gatherings (perhaps with a portable island rolling into place). There's the matter of the floor and the usual presence of a sink in the counter.
 
 
Feb 24, 2012
A friend of mine is an architect and here's what she said: regarding this article:

"The design things he talked about I am surrounded by everyday. it's not really a 30% up charge, more like double to triple. Design costs $, that's why it's why homes are rarely designed by architects, and even more rarely, good architects."
 
 
+4 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 24, 2012
This from a guy who complained about his modern toilet-paper holder that flung the roll across the room when he tried to tear off the paper...until someone pointed out he'd installed it bass-ackwards, as they work perfectly well if the open end is pointed toward the back of the toilet rather than the front.

There was no disclaimer, but I know enough not to take design advice from cartoonists.
 
 
Feb 24, 2012
To implement the real Apple model, we'd need to find a way to ship homes from China, where labor costs $130 per month for 72 hrs/week labor. Once you can put a near-infinite amount of labor into something, without having to pay for it, you can accomplish anything.
 
 
+7 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 24, 2012
People want to buy a home that they'll be able to resell, because most people are not expecting to die in the homes they're buying. This means not having anything strange or unique about the house, because that will reduce the number of people who would find it appealing. It's better to have strong interest from several people than probably no interest from anyone but maybe someone lusting after it if you're lucky.

Much of the stuff Scott describes is specialized. Many people don't have a dog, so the dog space would be a waste for them. Many people don't have a cat, many people don't need a home office, and so on. If you put all these features in a home (and all the other awesome features Scott didn't think of because he would never have a use for them), you end up with a house that's very unlikely to be the right house for anyone, because it has a bunch of features they don't care about (and a whole bunch of space in the house they can't use conveniently).

I don't care if I can't resell my phone. Even taking a big hit on reselling a car is not such a big deal. But I have to be able to resell my house as easily and profitably as possible.
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
In regards to fire places. Most fire places are built for aesthetic purposes only. Aesthetic fire places are extraordinary inefficient. What they do is look cool, while !$%*!$% all the warm air from the room .making the room colder... Hence why people don't use them.

Thermal radiant mass fire places on the other hand is the way to go. I don't have time to explain it, but you can look it up online...
 
 
+2 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 23, 2012
After having just purchased a new home a year ago I can agree, moving is a process I don't want to do again. Ever! Even with movers bringing the heavy stuff it's a royal pain. And, to be clear, I really like our new home. However, you are on to something Scott as I would consider another move if the home was compelling in the way that you describe.
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
I always pay attention to a homes geo orientation for utilization of solar energy, And air flow. Some reason modern home design ignores that huge nuclear fusion fire ball in he sky...
I also pay attention to Spaces that make me feel good as well. A coffee shop with a comfortable lounge room, A bathroom with a ton of saturated light in the mornings, a greenhouse...

Dimensions and energy flow are important . I look at building design like a electrical circuit.The materials, locations, orientations, and capacitances Can play a role in the psychology of a room.How a persons velocity/energy can change with a step or turn can make a room either active or inactive. Capacitance of a room can determine the enthalpy entropy, potential potentials of that room. More people = more mass= More energy.

Its the same logic.

Zen = physics
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
User-driven design would likely fail because there is a big difference between how people aspire to use their homes and how they actually use them.

I believe every house-hunter show on cable has a scene where the couple walks out onto a deck and says "This is great, we could drink coffee out here in the mornings." I sometimes wish they would do some kind of follow up show and ask how many times they actuall drink coffee on those decks. I guessing something close to zero.
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
And if you read Jobs' biography, you realize that the Master of Design did almost nothing with his own house(s). He could have built the most awesome house, but instead lived in a house with no furniture.
 
 
+2 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 23, 2012
When people want to throw more $$ at a house (even at the high end), it's usually for location (location & location). I've seen a school district boundary make a few hundred thousand difference in price.
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
Each room should be built like a large lego piece so that the rooms can be manufactured in bulk and then snapped into place in your final home. If you say lego pieces are boring, and not enough excitement to them, you haven't seen some of the amazing things my kids have built with them and how many different types of lego pieces there are.
 
 
+4 Rank Up Rank Down
Feb 23, 2012
There is a big difference between an iPhone and a house, especially when it comes to the life span of the product. A phone can be real cool but is obsolete in 2-3 years, and then you throw it away. A house is a much longer term investment. What is great now in convenience items will not be great in five years. I put a lot of convenience items in my house when I built it 10 years ago and many of those features I put in are obsolete now. Lots of wiring for phone and internet (now everything is wireless), PBX system with direct incoming calls to my kids without bothering me (they all use cell phones now), etc.

While people will pay a some premium for a smarter built house, it is hard to say how much more, and if they would even recognize it when they were purchasing. Part of this is the way loans work and appraisals, and that might be hard to change. If your house had some real special items that you feel should give you a premium price, try to explain that to an appraiser for your loan when doing comps. They are looking for number of rooms, square feet, neighborhood, and condition of home.

 
 
Feb 23, 2012
I'm a home design hobbyist. I read books about architecture, lighting, and livable home design. I've read (and own a copy of) Alexander's A Pattern Language. I've spent countless hours of my life trying (and failing) to design the world's most practical mud room. Floor plan after floor plan, I've been obsessed with designing a house containing the minimum needed square footage while still allowing for comfort and above all: utility. I'm also squarely in the middle of the disappearing middle class. I own an old home and realistically will never design & build a house, but I want to with a burning passion.

And if someone actually followed through with your idea - tested well-designed floor plans - It's possible that I would mortgage myself to my eyeballs. (Since I'm a hyper-financially-conservative CPA, this is really saying something.)
 
 
Feb 23, 2012
Scott, you ended your last sentence a little prematurely. I think you meant to add, "for the wealthiest 3%" to that. A good idea sure, but not necessarily one that will revitalize the housing industry. The only way out of that is time to allow credit to heal, relaxation of bank lending standards and government scrutiny to "balanced" levels, and an improving labor market.
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog