Scott Adams's Blog
 
Subscribe to RSS feed
I just invented a new holiday. It's called Negative Christmas. On this day, rather than giving gifts, you can force a family member or friend to discard one item that he or she already owns. The selected item might be a hideous shirt that you consider an abomination, or that pair of bedroom slippers that are an insult to all footwear. The idea is that the unrecipient should be better off without the item you ungift.

For example, let's say you have a single friend who has a collection of Star Wars memorabilia and also complains that he can't get a woman to stay the night. You could help by making him give away the full-sized wookie that he keeps next to his dresser. When the next Negative Christmas rolls around you could go after the collection of light sabers he keeps over his mantle. It might take you a few years to make any difference in his love life, but think of it as a project.

For real Christmas, people often give gifts of clothing or accessories so the recipient will look attractive. For Negative Christmas you could pay a crazy guy with tattoos to punch your friend in his soft tissue every time he eats a Big Mac or skips going to the gym. In the long run it will help your friend more than a new necktie.

During Negative Christmas there will be no need for vacuous greeting cards or festive salutations. For the entire month leading up to Negative Christmas you are expected to avoid eye contact and mumble insults about everyone you encounter. Ask yourself what would make you happier: 1. Getting a cheap greeting card or, 2. Calling someone a trout-faced bastard under your breath.

Negative Christmas would be every June 25th, on the opposite side of the calendar from Christmas. You would celebrate by planting a tree instead of killing one, and saving your money for yourself instead of blowing it on worthless crap for others.

Who's with me?
 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +46
  • Print
  • Email
  • Share

Comments

Sort By:
User Name: GneissG Jul 7, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
i like the idea! It's nice!
 
 
User Name: ldcroberts Jun 26, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Well your june 25th was pretty negative alright, i'm still sad. Rip MJ & FF.
 
 
User Name: T_Bird Jun 12, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
It already exists! Years ago, a Florida DJ named Jack Harris created "Leon" on June 25th. Why Leon? It's "Noel" spelled backwards.
 
 
User Name: unlost Jun 12, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
 
User Name: cavpollo Jun 12, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Im definetely with you
sounds like a great holiday
 
 
User Name: JJSmith Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
June 25 is already my wedding anniversary, so the general idea works well for me. (Although I guess this makes Christmas Day also my un-wedding anniversary. Hmmm.)
 
 
User Name: Uncollated Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
This will never take off. It's too much like the rest of the year.
 
 
User Name: god save England Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
someone suggested negative thanksgiving... surly that would be where any native amaricans send envolopes full of strange and new illnesses to the western world??

I'm all for Negative Xmas, Esp the trout faced bar steward bit. Would love to do that where i work, would make me feel soo much better. Instead of school holidays kids have to attend EXTRA school leaving some free time to their parents who would normally be busy buying presents and taking them screaming to see santa.

God Save Scott Adams!
 
 
User Name: Zowie Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
I'm afraid this will be abused to make everybode a bit more normal (aka mainstream) and eccentrics, geeks, dorks and nerds will be prominent victims. Imagine if everybody who knows you takes away one of your favorite weird objects... horror!

On the other hand, I think Scott deserves to get a new holiday for his birthday, but I hope he reconsiders.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY YOU MAGNIFICENT WEIRDO!
 
 
User Name: KevinKunreuther Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
I posted links back to this blog entry on Facebook, several environmental blogs, Dave Gilmour's blog (he's into replacing trees - me too BTW) and elsewhere 'round web, so hopefully this'll catch on beyond the Dilbert social network.

Perhaps a Facebook group and MySpace page, too?
 
 
User Name: april26 Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
My spouse has this boxing punch-bag that he's owned for 15 years but never used. He won't sell it, or donate it to the local gym. It's first on my list!

How about calling it X-Xmas. Actually can't we just take over Xmas - it's a better name for our idea anyway.
 
 
User Name: headhunt23 Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
I like the idea, not sure I like the name.

When I was in the Army in Germany, I had a commander that loved Christmas and celebrated it in the summer. He called it "Leon" (Noel spelled backwards). I always liked that.

So, if we can go with "Leon" I'm in.

I do need to ask, will their be an airing of the grievences and feats of strength?
 
 
User Name: gyrofx Jun 9, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
I'm in, but if anyone tells me to get rid of my wookie they will get punched in the face!
 
 
User Name: Frapazoid Jun 9, 2009
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Happy negative christmas! Now give up the keyboard you use to type up these ridiculous ideas.
 
 
User Name: keeffer Jun 8, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
i think this is one holiday where everyone would be in to giving, but not too keen on receiving.
 
 
User Name: chubbygirl Jun 8, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
I'm in! Especially the part about planting a tree and saving money instead of blowing it!
~ManDee
 
 
User Name: jcdill Jun 8, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Happy b-day! Here's some cereal.

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jcdill/3609830030/" title="cereal_box"><img src="http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3322/3609830030_beb4f193c4_o.jpg" width="200" height="200" alt="cereal_box.jpg" /></a>

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3322/3609830030_beb4f193c4_o.jpg
 
 
User Name: Leora Jun 8, 2009
+2 Rank Up Rank Down
Funny you should mention this. Several female friends have commented recently that they're glad their husbands are going away so they can ditch a bunch of his stuff. Is it just me, or does that seem a bit cruel? Surely an intelligent being can decide what crap to save and what to get rid of? Especially with the aid of his wife, who is surely more unbiased than he...

I still remember my father's face when he discovered that my mom gave away his favourite (and truly atrocious) chair--eerily similar to the look the dog gave us when he came home from the vet after being neutered.
 
 
User Name: crogers23 Jun 8, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Sounds like a Festivus for the rest of us!
 
 
User Name: arbyisme Jun 8, 2009
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Hmm, Happy Negative Valentine. The possibilities are endless….Am thinking more mildly, like letting all the air out of your old girl/boyfriend’s tires remembering that they broke your heart.
 
 
 

Dilbert 2.0 - 20 years of Dilbert

Old Dilbert Blog