Home
You're reading this blog, and that means there's a good chance that people ask you to help them solve computer problems. There are three types of users who ask for help: Runners, Watchers, and Squatters.

Runners are all too happy to abandon their workstations for as long as it takes you to solve their problems. When the runner is gone, you can think through a variety of potential solutions, try some things, and really dig in to the problem. Personally, I don't mind runners, although it makes me feel as if I should be getting paid for my services.

Watchers are the most thoughtful users. They might offer some useful information when asked, such as passwords. Perhaps they will compliment you on your computer skills and intuitions. And the Watcher is there when you find your brilliant solution. It's nice to have a witness sometimes. The only danger with a Watcher is that sometimes you get a talker.

The third type of users is Squatters. A Squatter will not leave his or her Chair of Control, and will insist on being the one to operate the mouse and keyboard. In theory, this shouldn't be too bad, at least for simple problems. But the Squatter will only give you a half listen. The other half of the squatter's brain is going rogue, occasionally checking in with you to say, "Click what?"

You could try to explain the situation to the squatter, but it won't help. For example, you might say, "If you relinquish the keyboard and mouse, I can probably solve this printer problem in one minute. If you continue asking me for advice while ignoring my input and randomly pursuing your own theories, we'll both be here all night."

Helping a squatter generally sounds like this.

You: Click the Start button

Squatter: What's a Clark button?

You: The Start button

Squatter: Where do I type Clark?

You: It's a button. You click it. I am pointing to it. Follow my finger. Don't look out the window. Don't yell at the dog. Focus on my finger. Click there.

Squatter: Click your finger? Is your name Clark?

Sometimes you'll get the half-squat, or even the quarter-squat. The half-squat is when the user keeps his chair but allows you to use the mouse and keyboard while he continues to sit directly in front of the monitor. The quarter-squatter only gives up one input device, such as the mouse alone or the keyboard alone.

I write about this because it is yet another problem for which the solution lies in naming the phenomena. If everyone agreed that the name for this situation is Squatting, it would be easier to talk a user out of doing it.

User: Can you help me fix this computer problem?

You: No, you're a Squatter.

 
 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +247
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
Apr 22, 2010
There are two types of squatters, good and bad. Good squatters learn from what you walk them through and the next time the problem happens they can fix it themselves. Sometimes they will even fix that problem when encountered by another user. Bad squatters only catch about half of what you show them, so the next time the problem happens they cause more damage than the initial problem by trying to fix it. Unfortunately they also will try to "help" other users, hence causing more problems. I guess it is yet another way the universe stays in balance..
 
 
Apr 10, 2010
I've noticed that squatters tend to say "You're going too fast." even though they're in a hurry for you to fix it.

Thanks for the addition to my vocabulary.
 
 
Apr 3, 2010
On two occasions, I've had someone ask for help, squat without moving and then knock my hand away when I reached for the mouse. That reaaaalllllyyy got me mad.
 
 
Apr 1, 2010
The behavior of Squatters sounds like behavior of A Boss.
 
 
Apr 1, 2010
Scott, MI5 is following your advice on how to deal with "ass bombers" :

Terrorists Could Use Explosives in Breast Implants to Crash Planes, Experts Warn

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2010/03/24/terrorists-use-explosives-breast-implants-crash-planes-experts-warn/
 
 
Apr 1, 2010
You forgot about the way this applies to folks who are supposed to show you how to use a new application or interface. There's nothing more satisfying then the instructor who pushes you out of the way, clicks in all the right places, and then says, "Okay, you got it, right?"
 
 
Apr 1, 2010
Well once having worked as a help desk IT support employee at a major parcel moving business that used the word Federal to sound more official. I was forced to work with squatters all the time, well we had a particularly temperamental printer from a company that rhymes with BMI, it would jam regularly or just stop the solution oddly enough was to raise the corner of the printer a few inches and drop it.
Well one day we had a call about such a problem and talking to a user I recommended the usual solution lift the printer and drop it. When I heard a loud crash I knew I should have been more specific.
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Apr 1, 2010
Nice.
I'm not a tech geek but I can work my way through some issues so people with less expertise than me often use me for tech support. When I run into a squatter I just say to them, "Sorry, I can't drive from the passenger seat. If you want me to try to fix it, shove over I need the mouse and keyboard". If they won't move over, I won't help. Call IT or Lifeline.
It would be funny though, when they refuse to move, to just stand up, point at them, and in my best John Cleese impersonation yell "Squatter" at them repeatedly.

When I call for help, I'm a watcher and a questioner. I won't offer advice, I constantly ask them to talk me through what they're doing so I can learn how to fix it myself next time.
 
 
Mar 31, 2010
I have to admit that I'm a watcher all the way ... and I prefer watchers when I'm working on someone's PC -- inevitably with runners, I need them to answer a question, then waste 20 minutes waiting for them to return.

There is however, 1 exception to this general rule ... when it's my home PC, I am a total runner leaving it to my husband to fix. I know when to bow to the Computer Gods!!
 
 
-3 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 31, 2010
Ha ha...words are funny.
 
 
Mar 31, 2010
The problem with runners is that they usually lock their computer before running, and then seem "put-out" when they return 20 minutes later to find the problem still exists. But at least you don't have to hear the runners opinion. The watcher and squatter both seem to have an abnormally elevated sense of technical expertise (makes you wonder why they called then) and feel that the technician should consider their advice ("Let's move the computer away from the window, I think a solar flare may changed my screen resolution").
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 31, 2010
@gyrofx
To answer your question: an Electrical Engineer. Trust me, my husband, has a lot of patience with me, a squatter. Like I said I promise to become a runner...almost there...but not quite.
 
 
-1 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 31, 2010
I'm a squatter.
I promise to become a runner from now on.
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 31, 2010
This may seem like a dumb question. What's a computer? Are you talking about this typewriter gizmo I'm clicking on? Mine always seems to work fine. Open the pod bay door HAL....
 
 
Mar 31, 2010
Squatters are denied help in my book, personally and professionally. On a personal note friends family must bring me their computer and I will get to it when I am not busy. That is the key to helping family/friends don't be to fast to fix the problem wait a few days to a week. Then you will only be bothered by the bigger issues (usually a re-format or blown out hard drive). They can't complain because its free ;)

@gyrofx
ROFL made me laugh harder than the post, "IE I recently inherited a computer that had the IE web blocking activated, which resulted in me having to hack the registry. (This is not to boast this is to illustrate a point)"

Editing Windows registry is hardly anything to boast about... That gets you about a 4 on a 10 scale, well wait -2 for saying hack in place of edit. You get a 2.
 
 
Mar 31, 2010
Shouldn't a quarter squatter
be half of half squatter,
which should make him more lenient squatter?
Or did you mean three quarter squatter.
 
 
Mar 31, 2010
Hilarious!!

I know someone who couldn't find reply button in gmail cause there are so many of them.
 
 
+6 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 31, 2010
I would say that I'm more of a "Squat-Watcher". I like to sit there and have you tell me how to fix the problem. It's a great way to learn. I will also give you a pat on the back by saying, "Wow, Joe! You really know computers! And, you're a great teacher!"

You will go away feeling happy and insulted for the rest of the day.

My brother was a network engineer for the FDA. He told me how one morning a simpleton from the floor below called his help desk. She was trying to explain a problem, but couldn't get past the first sentence: "I'm having a....uhhh...ummmm...what do you call it when...uhhhh...nothing works? Oh, and where's my keypunch machine?"

After telling her they phased out keypunches in the mid-1990s, my brother told her, "Okay, I might be able to help. I want you to look on your desktop and click "My Computer."

She replied in Clarkish fashion, "You want me to come up to your office?!"

And we wonder why there are so many problems with the Federal Govt....

 
 
Mar 31, 2010
classic. i thot only indians are like that. Seems the issue is international :P
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Mar 30, 2010
I'm a band director and web manager. (Education in the 21st century.)

For me, it's best to force everyone to be a squatter. Then they either learn how to solve problems, or they go to someone else for help.
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog