Home
Someone recently asked me how parents of identical twin babies can tell them apart. My first reaction was that even identical twins have tiny differences that a parent would notice. And I'm sure parents of twins have a labeling system. How hard could it be?

Then I reflected on how many times - in other walks of life - the average person screws up incredibly simple tasks with no provocation whatsoever.  In all likelihood, lots of twin babies have been accidentally switched at home, thanks to tired mothers, careless fathers, forgetful grandparents, and disgruntled babysitters.

I can imagine being in that situation myself. I'd strip down both babies to give them an efficient and simultaneous diaper change, and say to myself Remember the one on the right is Ryan. Right is Ryan. Right is Ryan. I'd be all proud of my memory trick right up until it was time to dress them in their identifiable outfits. Then I'd be wondering if the memory trick was right is Ryan or Bob is Nearest the Bed. I'd be too embarrassed to tell my wife I mixed up the babies and I'd settle it with a coin toss.

I know, I know. You're going to say twin babies usually have ankle bracelets or some sort of identifier that can't be screwed up. But no system is perfect. Sooner or later, my wife would hand me a new set of baby bracelets and ask me to change out the old ones. My incompetence is like rain on a flat roof. If there's a hole, I'll find it.

Anyway, back to the original question: Does it really matter if you mix up the twin babies after you bring them home? I gave the question some brief but intense thought, and I concluded that it didn't matter at all. Arguably, all you're doing is switching the names of the babies, and not the babies themselves. It's the ultimate victimless crime. And yet it still seems very wrong.

If you're the father of adult identical twins, here's a good prank to play on your spouse. One day, out of nowhere, casually confess that decades ago you switched the babies' bracelets when they were three weeks old just to see if your wife would notice. Explain that when she didn't notice the switch, you didn't bother to fix it, figuring it didn't matter. You might want to record your wife's reaction on a hidden camera. That could be gold.

This seems like a good time to remind you not to get marriage advice from cartoonists.

On a related note, I'm wondering why there has never been a movie about identical twin criminals. One twin might commit crimes in front of witnesses, and on security video, and yet no jury could ever get past reasonable doubt. The trick is to make sure the other twin has no alibi at the time of the crime.

This is also a good time to remind you that you shouldn't embark on a crime spree based on the advice of cartoonists, no matter how awesome it might be.

And yes, I'm still running for president of the United States. There's a good chance I'll forget the nuclear codes and accidentally disarm the country. But consider who I might be running against. Ron Paul would stop guarding the nukes. Newt would scare North Korea into a preemptive attack. Obama has been bitch-slapping Pakistan for months, probably because he stopped smoking. There's no clear choice here.
 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +85
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
+4 Rank Up Rank Down
Dec 23, 2011
My father is an identical twin- and while he and his brother never engaged in criminal activity (beyond taking each other's tests in school), they were life-long pranksters. When my uncle managed to score a date with a girl they both liked, my father called her up and changed the time to an hour earlier. They were endlessly messing with each other's reputation among friends and neighbors. I can't imagine how being switched after birth would make any difference. Chaos by any other name...
 
 
Dec 22, 2011
How to make it so the audience knows about the twin without knowing it is the twin doing it? Otherwise it is one of those "surprise the .... did it" blind sides. I guess that you would need a writer/director that was excellent about foreshadowing and slight misdirection. Otherwise it will end up being a movie that is less about the story and more about sitting back for 2 hours to watch another rendition of the thing that is just like the other thing in that one movie that you saw last month.
 
 
Dec 21, 2011
My kid wasn't a twin, but I was sufficiently paranoid about the possibility that she would be mixed up in the nursery, that as soon as she was born, I picked out an identifying characteristic. Turns out that one eyelid had a bit of a skin blemish which looked like a backwards C; there were other marks but that was the most useful. It was distinctive enough that I never had any doubt that I was taking home my little girl. (oh, and my wife's too, I guess). Also, since she was Caesarian born, she was the only infant with a nice round head among all the pointy-headed babies.

If any further confirmation were needed that she was related to me, it was confirmed when she was about 13 and developed an excessive liking for Star Trek and Monty Python.

Not sure what you'd do about identitwins, especially when the stigmata faded after a few days. Ever considered branding?

Helm
 
 
Dec 21, 2011
Dogs can tell twins apart by scent, even if they have the same diet.
 
 
+2 Rank Up Rank Down
Dec 21, 2011
Sorry Scott. Ron Paul would make a better President than you. On the positive side he's probably not a good cartoonist.
 
 
Dec 21, 2011
ha, great post. I am an identical twin, and my parents had a labeling system where all of our clothes had our names sewn in. One day while changing, she mixed us up. We ended up at the hospital getting foot printed to confirm our !$%*!$%*!$% Not really sure why fingerprints weren't good enough, but there you go. And yes, I've given the crime a lot of thought. Aside from looking alike, the other advantage is that identical twins have identical DNA. Boo-yah.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Dec 21, 2011
Mr. Adams;

You did it again. You are inferring that we don't have identical twins for potential presidential candidates we have triplets. However, we can distinguish them apart. But are they really different ? As you are also running for that office, does that turn the contest into a quadruplet race ? Maybe you are different, as per your blog several days ago. If you are different, I will write your name in on election day. Hey, you got one vote. Anyway good luck.

JAXID
 
 
Dec 21, 2011
The film that did the twin thing - although I think ambiguously rather than evilly - the best for me might be The Prestige.
 
 
Dec 21, 2011

That is why it is said that "the law is an ass."
 
 
Dec 21, 2011
Professor Leo Katz of UPenn's Law Faculty writes about this precise problem (which he calls the "Twin Paradox") in his book "Ill-gotten gains: evasion, blackmail, fraud, and kindred puzzles of the law". He writes:

"An undisguised man robs a bank in New York. A camera records the entire episode, wanted-posters with his likeness are plastered across the country and someone is soon arrested. At the very time that the bank robbery occurred in New York, another man, also undisguised, commits a murder in Los Angeles. As luck will have it, his actions too are recorded by a camera, wanted-posters with his likeness are plastered everywhere, and someone is soon arrested. But then there is a snag: the two arrested men, it turns out, are identical twins; thus, despite the wonderfully clear-cut photographic evidence available, it is impossible to decide which of them committed the bank robbery and which committed the murder. The defendants deny all guilt.
The two cases are joined and tried before a judge, who disposes of the case by declaring both defendants guilty of bank robbery and imposing commensurate sentences. His reasoning is simple: we know beyond a reasonable doubt that one of the defendants is guilty of bank robbery and one of them is guilty of murder, but we don’t know who committed which crime. Whatever the truth, no defendant will end up with less than a sentence for bank robbery; therefore, it is fair to sentence them for that offense.
How will the judge’s verdict fare on appeal? Very poorly. Any appellate court following the common understanding of the proof-beyond-a-reasonable-doubt requirement will insist that the crime of which the defendant is convicted (in this case bank robbery) be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. This has not been done. Therefore, the verdict cannot stand."
 
 
+7 Rank Up Rank Down
Dec 20, 2011
And I don't see how Ron Paul wouldn't protect the nukes. As he says, "I'm pro defense, anti empire."
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Dec 20, 2011
See scott, I be you've developed your own blogging formula at this point. I imagine that it is sort of like your "at least two, sexy, cute, bizarre, etc" formula for cartoons. In every blog, you have to mention either politics and technology, technology and family, life and politics, technology and sex, or some other combination of two. I wonder if you spin a big wheel.

And I didn't mean this as an insult, as it seems like you have the analytical mind that likes to come up with simple formulas.
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
Well, at least you didn't suggest waiting until the twins were old enough to say their names and then try to convince them that you switched them. It'd be comedy gold for them to watch them run off to their moms screaming that they don't know who they are... or use that info to screw with mom.
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
In the story below it mentions "An accomplice". The accomplice was Ronnie Lee Gardner's girlfriend and an identical twin. Even though several witness's saw her pass the gun to Ronnie no one could testify which twin was which. His girlfriend was never even charged.


Gardner's path to execution began in 1985, when he was sentenced to death for shooting and killing attorney Michael Burdell during an attempted escape from a Salt Lake City courthouse in April of that year. An accomplice smuggled a gun to Gardner while he was in the courthouse on charges of killing Melvyn John Otterstrom during a 1984 robbery at Cheers Tavern.

Incidentally the girlfriend's twin hated Ronnie so there really is no doubt which girl passed him the gun.
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
similar scenarios also occur in "The Good Thief" and "A Tale of Two Cities" (although in the latter case it was a doppelgänger and not a twin).
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
similar scenarios also occur in "The Good Thief" and "A Tale of Two Cities" (although in the latter case it was a doppelgänger and not a twin).
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
Might matter to the kids if you named twin girls Crystal and Brunhilda. I'm guessing one of them would be pretty pissed off to learn that she'd been accidentally switched during infancy.
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
Not quite identical criminals but it seems the attorney had not thought out the plan all the way.
http://www.kansascity.com/2011/12/15/3322466/double-trouble-for-kc-lawyer-who.html
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
Hi Scott

sherlock holmes and the Case of the Silk Stocking as the twins in it too. I've know a couple of sets of identical twins and i can tell them apart. I guess they are just very similer

cheers
 
 
Dec 20, 2011
No worries - Most identical twins have SOME minor but noticeable difference (birthmark, etc).

And Law and Order did the twin criminal thing years ago
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog