This time Wally is completely right! There are a wide variety of possible issues with any document. Reviewing for any and all issues is just impractical. He may make a long list - upsetting others, especially if document is urgent. Or he may miss one - and be blamed for it.
In one aspect, I can see Wally's point. What issues should the engineer be looking for? But on the other hand, I can see her point as she most likely does not know which issues need to be addressed. Thus, we have a no win scenario.
Ok, I'm scaring myself. I have just tried to defend both parties.